I'm very happy to have found this thread. I have been using Wild Man Beard Oil Raven for a couple weeks. I had no reason to choose this over any of the others available except it was relatively cheap and widely available on Amazon. I like it, but I don't love it. The scent is decent but I wish it lasted longer. My beard is only marginally softer. Maybe I am expecting too much, but after reading these reviews I am excited to try some great new products! Thanks everyone!